Sunday, November 22, 2020

Stages in Criminal Cases

 Stages in Criminal Cases In India Under Criminal Procedure Code,





A. Pre-trial stage

B. Trial stage

C. Post-trial stage

Now, each stage having some steps to be fulfilled they are :

 

A. Pre-trial Stage

1 Commission of an offence (cognizable or non cognizable)

first we need to understand what is cognizable & non coginzable

Cognizable Offence:

A cognizable offence is an offence in which the police officer as per the first schedule or under any other law for the time being in force, can arrest the convict without a warrant and can start an investigation without the permission of the court. Cognizable offences are generally heinous or serious in nature such as murder, rape, kidnapping, theft, dowry death etc. The first information report (FIR) is registered only in cognizable crimes.

Under section 154 Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC), a police officer is bound to register an FIR in case of a cognizable crime

Non-Cognizable Offence:

A non-cognizable offence is the offence listed under the first schedule of the Indian Penal Code and is bailable in nature. In case of a non-cognizable offence, the police cannot arrest the accused without a warrant as well as cannot start an investigation without the permission of the court. The crimes of forgery, cheating, defamation, public nuisance, etc., fall in the category of non-cognizable crimes.


2. A. Information to police.

B. Complaint to magistrate. 


A. Information to police :

a. Information of cognizable offence.

b. Information of non cognizable offence.

a. Information of cognizable offence :

Under Section 154 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, a FIR or First Information Report is registered. FIR puts the case into motion. A FIR is information given by someone (aggrieved) to the police relating to the commitment of an offense.

b. Information of non cognizable offence :

In case of non cognizable offence N.C.R (non cognizable report) is registered by police under section 155 of Cr.P.C. but the police cannot start investigation or arrest the accused without the order of a Magistrate having power to try such case.

B. Complaint to magistrate - Section 2 (d) of the Code of Criminal Procedure defines the term 'complaint as any allegation made orally or in writing to a Magistrate, with a view to his taking action under this Code, that some person, whether known or unknown, has committed an offence, but does not include a police report. On receipt of a complaint a Magistrate has several courses open to him.

He may take cognizance of the offence and proceed to record the statements of the complainant and the witnesses present under Section 200, Cr Thereafter if in his opinion there is no sufficient ground for proceeding he may dismiss the complaint under Section 203, Cr PC. If in his opinion there is sufficient ground for proceeding he may issue process under Section 204, Cr PC.

However, if he thinks fit, he may postpone the issue of process and either inquire into the case himself or direct an investigation to be made by a police officer or such other person as he thinks fit for the purpose of deciding whether or not there is sufficient ground for proceeding (Section 202, Cr PC).

He may then issue process if in his opinion there is sufficient ground for proceeding or dismiss the complaint if there is no sufficient ground for proceeding.


3. Investigation by Police :- Police conduct investigation for

1)  For collection of evidence;

2)  Interrogation statement of accused;

3) Statement of witnesses;

4)  Scientific analysis / opinion if required. During this time, at any stage decided by investigating agency, accused persons can be arrested.

In case of cognizable offence police can start investigation after the registration of FIR, no prior approval of magistrate is necessary. But in case of non cognizable offence, prior approval of magistrate is necessary to start investigation.


4. Anticipatory Bail :- Upon registration of FIR for cognizable criminal offence the accused may make an application for anticipatory bail in session court or high court. If anticipatory bail is granted then the accused cannot be arrested. If anticipatory bail is rejected then the accused can be arrested without warrant.


5. Arrest of the Accused :- In case of cognizable offence police can arrest the accused without warrant. However in case of non cognizable offence prior approval of magistrate is necessary.


6. Production of accused to magistrate :- Within 24 hours of the arrest the accused shall be produced before a magistrate having jurisdiction to try such cases.


7. Remand :- Whenever an accused is arrested for any offence and police cannot complete investigation within 24 hours then such person is produced before a magistrate for seeking extension of police or magisterial custody.


8. After investigation is completed:- If investigating agency feels a prima facie case is made out, charge sheet is filed in Court through the public prosecutor. If police feels that no prima facie case is made out, a final report filed in Court.


9. Cognizance of Offence by Magistrate :- After filling of charge sheet the next stage is taking cognizance of offence by magistrate under section 190 of the Criminal Procedure Code. In the language of the Hon'ble Apex Court employed in its earliest decision R.R.Chari v. State of U.P AIR 1951 SC 207 “taking cognizance does not involve any formal action or indeed action of any kind but occurs as soon as a Magistrate as such applies his mind to the suspected commission of offence"


10. Service of summons/warrant to accused and Process to compel appearance under chapter 6 of Cr.P.C.


11. Appearance of accused before court & engagement of advocate.


12. Filing bail application/ furnishing surety.


13. Decision is taken by the Court after hearing the public prosecutor and the counsel for defence:

A. On question of Charge sheet:

a. Court can reject charge sheet, in which case the accused is discharged. Or,

b. Court can accept that a prima facie case is made out, frame the charges, and post the case for trial. Case goes to next stage.

a. Court can accept the final report- case is closed and accused is discharged. Or,

b. Court can reject the final report, and direct the police to further investigate the case. Case goes back to the Stage of investigation. Or, c. If the Court direct the case to be posted for trial. Case goes to next stage.


14. Framing Of Charge :- After considering the police report and other important documents the accused is not discharged then the court frames charges under which he is to be trialed.

 

15. Conviction on plea of guilty :- If the accused pleads guilty, the court shall record the plea and may, at discretion convicts the accused.


16. If the accused pleads not guilty. Case is posted for trial.


B. Trial stage


17. Commencement of trial - Generally speaking trial of a case commences when the case is posted for examination of witnesses. Trial may be -

a. Sessions trial

b. Warrant trial

c. Summons trial

d. Summary trial


18. Prosecution evidence:- After the charges are framed, and the accused pleads guilty, then the court requires the prosecution to produce evidence to prove the guilt of the accused. The prosecution is required to support their evidence with statements from its witnesses. This process is called "examination in chief". The magistrate has the power to issue summons to any person as a witness or orders him to produce any document.


19. Statement of the accused:- Section 313 of the Criminal Procedure Code gives an opportunity to the accused to be heard and explain the facts and circumstances of the case. The statements of accused are not recorded under oath and can be used against him in the trial.


20. Defence evidence:- An opportunity is given to the accused in a case where he is not being acquitted to produce so as to defend his case. The defense can produce both oral and documentary evidence. In India, since the burden of proof is on the prosecution the defense, in general, is not required to give any defense evidence.


21. Final Arguments:- Public Prosecutor and the defence counsel present their arguments.


22. Judgment and sentence by the Court:- The final decision of the court with reasons given in support of the acquittal or conviction of the accused is known as judgment.


23. Arguments on sentence:- When the accused is convicted, then both sides are invited to give arguments on the punishment which is to be awarded. This is usually done when the person is convicted of an offense whose punishment is life imprisonment or capital punishment.

However when the sentence is pronounced in a summons case, the parties need not argue on the amount of punishment given. The sentence is the sole discretion of the judge.


24. Judgment of Court passing sentence:- After the arguments on sentence, the court finally decides what should be the punishment for the accused. While punishing a person, the courts consider various theories of punishment like reformative theory of punishment and deterrent theory of punishment. Court also considers the age, background and history of an accused and the judgment is pronounced accordingly.


C. Post-Trial Stage


25. Appeal (within specified period of limitation)/Revision :- Appeal can be filed by party aggrieved by judgment on acquittal / conviction /sentence. On notice being issued to the opposite parties, arguments are placed before Appellate court by defence counsel and the public prosecutor. Or,

Revision Application :

Where there is right of appeal provided but no appeal was filed then in its discretion the Sessions Court or the High Court can entertain a revision to prevent miscarriage of Justice occurred by the orders of the lower court.


26. Judgment of the Appellate Court or Court having revisional jurisdiction.


27. Execution of Sentence.

Thursday, November 12, 2020

EVIDENCE AS PER INDIAN LAW

 What is Evidence under Indian Evidence Act,



Evidence is  that which tends to prove or disprove something; ground for belief OR proof. 
every case depends upon evidence, without evidence no lawyer can prove the case in favour of his  client



There are various types of evidences under the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. These are mentioned below-

1) Oral Evidence

2) Documentary Evidence

3)Primary Evidence

4) Secondary Evidence

5) Real Evidence

6) Hearsay Evidence

7) Judicial Evidence

8) Non- Judicial Evidence

9) Direct Evidence

10) Indirect Evidence or Circumstantial Evidence

11) Forensic Evidence

12) Digital Evidence

These are elaborated below-

1) Oral Evidence–  Section 60 of the Indian Evidence Act explains Oral Evidence. Oral Evidences are those evidences which are personally seen or heard by the witness giving them and not heard or told by some one else. All the statements which are permitted by the court or the court expects the witness to make such statements in his presence regarding the truth of the facts, are called as Oral Evidences.

Oral evidences must always be direct. An Evidence is direct when it establishes the main fact in issue.

2) Documentary Evidences –  are defined under section 3 of the Act. All those documents which are presented in the court for inspection regarding a case, such documents are known as documentary evidences.

3) Primary Evidence – Section 62 of the Indian Evidence Act defines Primary Evidence. Primary evidences are the most superior class of evidences. These are those evidences which are expected by the law and admissible and permissible at the first place. These are those evidences which in any possible condition gives the vital hint in a disputed fact and establishes through documentary evidence on the production of an original document by the court.

4) Secondary Evidences – are defined under section 63 of the Act. These are those evidences which are entertained by the court in the absence of the Primary evidences. Therefore it is known as secondary evidences.

5) Real Evidences – Real evidences are those evidences which are real or material evidences.  Real evidence or proof of a fact is brought to the knowledge of the court by an inspection of a physical object rather than by deriving an information by a witness or a document.

6) Hearsay Evidences –  Hearsay evidences are the ones which the witness has neither personally seen nor heard, nor has he percieved through his senses, but are those which have come to his knowledge through some other person. These are the most weak category of evidences.

7) Judicial Evidence – Judicial evidences are those which are given before the magistrate in the court. For example-  a confession made by the accused before the magistrate in the court is an Judicial Evidence.

8) Non- Judicial Evidence –  Any confession made by the accused outside the court and not in front of the magistrate but in the presence of some other person are termed as Non- Judicial evidences.

9) Direct Evidence –  Direct evidences are those evidences which establishes a fact. The best example of a direct evidence would be statement or confessions made by the witnesses.

10) Indirect or Circumstantial Evidence –  Circumstantial or indirect evidence are the ones which attempts to prove the facts in dispute by providing other facts. Circumstantial evidences are not definite proof. they only provide a general idea as to what occurred at the  crime scene

11) Forensic Evidence -Forensic Evidence is scientific evidence, such as DNA, trace evidence, fingerprints or ballistics reports, and can provide proof to establish a person’s guilt or innocence. Forensic evidence is generally considered to be strong and reliable evidence and alongside helping to convict criminals, its role in exonerating the innocent has been well documented. The term “forensic” means “for the courts”. Its use in workplace investigations is generally limited to serious cases that may end up in court.

12) Digital Evidence-Digital evidence can be any sort of digital file from an electronic source. This includes email, text messages, instant messages, files and documents extracted from hard drives, electronic financial transactions, audio files, video files. Digital evidence can be found on any server or device that stores data, including some lesser-known sources such as home video game consoles, GPS sport watches and internet-enabled devices used in home automation. Digital evidence is often found through internet searches using open source intelligence